New

From idea to ETF portfolio in minutes. Build yours now →

Advertisement
Advertisement
Smart Investing

How to choose between robo-advisors and All-in-One ETFs?

Automate portfolio construction with robo-advisors or All-in-One ETFs. Explore what they are, the benefits and drawbacks of each and more.

Justin Ho - Writer for NYSE ETF Central
By Justin Ho · June 14, 2022
Share
How to choose between robo-advisors and All-in-One ETFs?

Keep up with what matters in ETFs

Get timely ETF insights, market trends, and top ideas straight to your inbox.

Your newsletter subscriptions with us are subject to ETF Central's Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

In the past, investing required the manual construction of a portfolio and the selection of individual securities. However, times have changed, and it is easier in the modern world to automate portfolio construction, asset allocation, and security selection. Two ways to make the investing process easier are robo-advisors or an All-in-One ETF. In this article, both these alternatives are explored further.

Report

Global ETF Survey 2026 is Live!

With 1,790 new products launched by July 2026, choosing is harder than ever. Our Global ETF Survey 2026, built on 620 professional investors and allocators, shows how active, fixed income, options-based and thematic ETFs are reshaping fund selection.

Explore Results

What are robo-advisors?

Many people have historically relied on human financial advisors to assist with customer service, bank account servicing, goal setting, financial education, and portfolio management when considering personal finance issues. In the modern era, financial advisors no longer need to be human.

Robo-advisors are digital platforms that, through algorithms and automation, can provide financial advisory services to people without the reliance on human supervision. You have probably encountered these robo-advisors when filling out online questionnaires relating to your financial circumstances and personal risk tolerance.

Robo-advisors rely on historical data to inform its advice and therefore based on the answers to the questionnaire, can provide optimal advice and suggestions.

Robo-advisors can take control of a portfolio's asset allocation if given the authority to do so. The robo-advisor only needs to be given parameters and other special considerations, and with that information, can construct a portfolio. For example, an investor may limit their allocation strategy to a maximum of 50% invested in equities. However, within that parameter, the robo-advisor can allocate the portfolio as it sees fit. 

What are All-in-One ETFs?

An All-in-One ETF or Multi-Asset Class ETF is an instrument that allows an investor to invest in multiple asset classes through a single ETF. With this instrument, investors can gain the diversification benefits of investing in multiple asset classes. Furthermore, All-in-One ETFs remove the complications and trading costs of investing in the individual asset classes.

All-in-One ETFs are generally managed and rebalanced by a portfolio manager. Multi-Asset Class ETFs may employ an active strategy of rebalancing based on market expectations, while some may adopt a more passive buy-and-hold strategy. The ETF strategy will influence the management expense ratio, with more active management requiring greater oversight and consequently higher fees.

All-in-One ETFs simplify the investing process, allowing investors to gain diversification and reduce investment risk, hassle, and costs. If an All-in-One ETF is not used, investors need to seek out individual securities and gain exposure to the separate asset classes individually. This is a complex process for those unfamiliar with asset allocation strategies.

With an All-in-One ETF, an investor needs to simply identify an ETF that uses a strategy that aligns with what the investor is looking for. They only need to purchase one type of security to gain the asset allocation exposure they would like. 

Benefits and drawbacks of robo-advisors vs. All-in-One ETFs

Both robo-advisors and All-in-One ETFs are more efficient methods of constructing a portfolio for those unfamiliar with the process. However, there are some differences in the benefits and drawbacks of each. 

Benefits of robo-advisors are:

  • Low-cost alternative to traditional advisors
  • More accessible, e.g. available 24/7 via the internet
  • Efficiency 

Drawbacks of robo-advisors are:

  • No human element, and therefore issues can arise relating to service
  • Authority over decisions and exposures is removed

Benefits of All-in-One ETFs are:

  • A low-cost way of achieving a high level of diversification
  • Relatively lower fees than other actively managed mutual funds
  • Automatic rebalancing

Drawbacks of All-in-One ETFs are:

  • “One-size-fits-all” approach, minimal customization for individual investors’ requirements and constraints
  • Subject to market risk factors like any individual security, for example, liquidity in sparsely traded ETFs can increase trading costs 

The main differences are that a robo-advisor is automated and must be given direction from the investor. In contrast, All-in-One ETFs are professionally managed and adhere to a strategy that investors do not influence. 

Some individuals are less trusting of algorithms and may prefer a human portfolio manager. In this case, an All-in-One ETF may be a more suitable alternative.

On the other hand, some individuals would want a more tailored strategy that is not available through an ETF; therefore, a robo-advisor may be a more suitable alternative.

Advertisement
Advertisement
ETF U
Become a better investor with NYSE: The Home of ETFs
Visit the ETF U homepage
ETF Guides
Advertisement

Recent educational content

ETF Investing Trends

First Look ETF

First Look ETF: Conventional and Unconventional International ETFs

First Look ETF’s November episode covers record-setting ETF launches and inflows with the NYSE, William Blair’s new active international and emerging markets ETFs, and the launch of the Long Nook Uncommon Compounders ETF (LUNC).

ETF Guide
By ETF Guide · November 19, 2026
Tidal ETF Industry KPIs

ETF Trends

ETF Industry KPIs November 16, 2026

This week’s KPI data overview highlights key metrics and trends shaping the ETF landscape.

Tidal
By Tidal · November 17, 2026
Tidal ETF Industry KPIs

ETF Trends

ETF Industry KPIs November 9, 2026

This week’s KPI data overview highlights key metrics and trends shaping the ETF landscape.

Tidal
By Tidal · November 9, 2026
Tidal ETF Industry KPIs

ETF Trends

ETF Industry KPIs November 3, 2026

This week’s KPI data overview highlights key metrics and trends shaping the ETF landscape.

Tidal
By Tidal · November 3, 2026

Browse all educational columns

Advertisement
New Report

ETFs’ Next Act: From Access to Selection

Global ETF Survey 2026