New

Global ETF Survey Is Live! 600+ ETF Professionals Weigh In. See Results →

Contributor

Exchange-Traded Interval Funds: An Interesting Idea, but What Happens When Markets Get Ugly?

An exchange listing gives investors a way to sell. It doesn't guarantee someone will be willing to buy at the right price.

Nicholas Phillips
By Nicholas Phillips · November 17, 2026
Share
Exchange-Traded Interval Funds: An Interesting Idea, but What Happens When Markets Get Ugly?

Keep up with what matters in ETFs

Get timely ETF insights, market trends, and top ideas straight to your inbox.

Your newsletter subscriptions with us are subject to ETF Central's Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

I'm Nicholas Phillips, President of ETF Capital Markets Advisors LLC, with 27 years of experience in ETF trading and capital markets.

I provide fractional capital markets support to ETF issuers and asset managers, helping them navigate launches, liquidity, ETF market structure, market maker relationships, and sales and execution support.

Through my contributions to ETF Central, I aim to provide practical insights for investors and issuers navigating the ETF landscape.

In my latest piece, I explore how BlackRock’s proposed ETIF structure could reshape access to private markets, and the liquidity challenges it may face during periods of market stress.

Report

Global ETF Survey 2026 is Live!

With 1,790 new products launched by July 2026, choosing is harder than ever. Our Global ETF Survey 2026, built on 620 professional investors and allocators, shows how active, fixed income, options-based and thematic ETFs are reshaping fund selection.

Explore Results

BlackRock’s ETIFs: The Liquidity Question

BlackRock's recent SEC application proposing a new structure called an exchange-traded interval fund (ETIF) caught my attention.

Having spent much of my career making markets in ETFs, I find the concept interesting. It's a thoughtful attempt to combine the trading convenience of an ETF with the investment flexibility of an interval fund, potentially giving investors broader access to private credit, private equity, and other less-liquid investments.

I can see the appeal. Investors could buy and sell shares throughout the trading day, while the fund could hold investments that aren't necessarily suitable for a traditional ETF structure.

But there's one question I keep coming back to: What happens when markets get ugly?

A Different Approach to Exchange-Traded Liquidity

Under BlackRock's proposal, ETIF shares would trade on an exchange, with authorized participants (APs) creating shares in large blocks, much like traditional ETFs.

The important difference is on the redemption side.

Rather than offering daily redemptions, ETIFs would conduct monthly repurchase offers. The proposed structure would permit monthly offers as low as 2% of outstanding shares, although individual funds could establish higher minimums. If requests exceed the amount offered, APs could receive only partial repurchases.

Repurchases would be available to APs, not directly to individual investors, and could involve cash, securities, or a combination of both.

I understand the rationale. A fund investing in private markets cannot necessarily provide the same portfolio liquidity as one holding publicly traded equities. The structure attempts to balance that reality with more frequent trading opportunities for investors.

It's a reasonable approach to a difficult problem.

Will It Trade Like an ETF or a Closed-End Fund?

Traditional ETFs benefit from a creation/redemption mechanism that gives market participants an economic incentive to keep share prices reasonably aligned with underlying portfolio values.

ETIFs would introduce an important asymmetry.

When demand is strong, APs could potentially create additional shares. But when investors are selling, the ability to return shares to the fund would be limited by monthly repurchase windows and available capacity.

BlackRock acknowledges in its application that the structure could produce larger discounts than conventional ETFs, while arguing that AP participation could improve pricing relative to traditional closed-end funds.

That seems reasonable. But a market maker buying shares at a discount would still need to consider how long it might have to hold the position and how much inventory it could successfully tender in the next repurchase offer.

Those uncertainties have a cost.

Valuation and Hedging Become More Difficult

Another challenge is determining what the underlying investments are actually worth.

Unlike publicly traded stocks, private credit and private equity investments don't have continuously updating market prices.

ETIFs would be subject to established fund valuation requirements, including SEC Rule 2a-5. But even a properly calculated fair-value NAV may be difficult for market makers to validate when underlying assets rarely trade and market conditions are changing rapidly.

During a significant selloff, credit spreads can widen, comparable investments can decline sharply, and liquidity can disappear. Even a recently calculated fair-value NAV may not reflect what buyers are actually willing to pay for the underlying assets.

For market makers, that raises an important question: How much confidence can they place in reported valuations when there may be few observable transactions to validate them?

Hedging adds another complication. Equity indexes or credit derivatives may offset some exposure, but they won't necessarily track the fund's private investments.

Without confidence in valuations, reliable hedges, or certainty about how much inventory can be repurchased, market makers may require substantial discounts before committing capital.

March 2020 Offers an Important Lesson

The COVID market disruption provides a useful comparison.

During March 2020, many fixed-income ETFs traded at substantial discounts to reported NAV as liquidity in the underlying bond market deteriorated.

Importantly, the in-kind redemption mechanism generally continued to function. Market makers could redeem ETF shares and receive the underlying bonds.

The challenge was determining what those bonds were actually worth.

Dealer bids were scarce or significantly lower than reported valuations, and market participants were reluctant to accumulate securities they might struggle to sell.

In some cases, ETF prices provided a more current indication of where the underlying bonds could actually trade than reported NAV.

Now consider an ETIF holding private-market investments.

Market makers could face similar valuation uncertainty and limited hedging alternatives, but with the additional constraint of monthly repurchases and potentially limited capacity.

Even if the structure operates exactly as designed, the discount necessary to attract buyers during a market disruption could be substantial.

The Real Test Comes During Market Stress

BlackRock's proposal is an interesting development, and its monthly repurchase mechanism could provide more pricing discipline than a traditional closed-end fund without comparable regular repurchase opportunities.

In normal markets, particularly with healthy investor demand and competing liquidity providers, ETIFs might trade reasonably well.

But when investors want liquidity at the same time, market makers become more selective about committing capital.

Having spent years making markets in ETFs, that's the environment that would concern me most as an investor.

Exchange trading provides the ability to sell shares throughout the day. It doesn't guarantee the ability to sell them at prices close to reported NAV.

BlackRock's proposed ETIF structure may prove to be a valuable addition to the investment landscape. But its real test won't come when markets are calm. It will come when investors want to sell, market makers are reluctant to buy, and the ability to exit through the fund is limited.

That's when we'll learn how much liquidity the structure can really provide—and at what price.

Disclaimer

Please note this article is for information purposes only and does not in any way constitute investment advice. It is essential that you seek advice from a registered financial professional prior to making any investment decision.

Advertisement
ETF U
Become a better investor with NYSE: The Home of ETFs
Visit the ETF U homepage
ETF Guides
Advertisement

Recent educational content

Tidal ETF Industry KPIs

ETF Trends

ETF Industry KPIs November 16, 2026

This week’s KPI data overview highlights key metrics and trends shaping the ETF landscape.

Tidal
By Tidal · November 17, 2026
Tidal ETF Industry KPIs

ETF Trends

ETF Industry KPIs November 9, 2026

This week’s KPI data overview highlights key metrics and trends shaping the ETF landscape.

Tidal
By Tidal · November 9, 2026
Tidal ETF Industry KPIs

ETF Trends

ETF Industry KPIs November 3, 2026

This week’s KPI data overview highlights key metrics and trends shaping the ETF landscape.

Tidal
By Tidal · November 3, 2026
ETF Investing Trends - First Look

First Look ETF

First Look ETF: Income, International, and Cash Flow ETFs

In this season 6 episode of First Look ETF, Stephanie Stanton ‪@etfguide‬ examines the latest ETF marketplace trends with NYSE and guests.

ETF Guide
By ETF Guide · October 20, 2026

Browse all educational columns

Advertisement
New Report

ETFs’ Next Act: From Access to Selection

Global ETF Survey 2026